Climate & Environment

What Our Climate Projections Miss (Some Assembly Required)

11.19.26 | 4 min read | Text by Julia Herrle & Megan Husted

We (Julia and Megan) are back from the Global Risk and Stabilization Summit that took place in Iceland last month, where we gathered with over 250 researchers, funders, policy analysts, advocates, Indigenous leaders, and entrepreneurs from six continents around the topic of the increasingly non-linear and catastrophic risks we face from climate change. Despite ongoing debate regarding framing, terminology, and the contours of “the field,” we were struck by a consensus among attendees that feels different from other climate spaces. Across presentations by climate scientists, hallway conversations with young activists, and workshop discussions with fellow NGO participants, we heard a common acknowledgement: scientific models, environmental policies, and the public imagination are missing critical pieces of the climate puzzle. 

By now, we have all heard that limiting temperature overshoot to 1.5°C is unattainable. Our missing puzzle pieces tell us that our new goals might already be void as well. The first puzzle piece is Earth’s declining reflectivity. The Earth is reflecting less sunlight, driving an increase in earth’s energy imbalance (EEI), or the difference between incoming energy from sunlight and outgoing energy as reflection and thermal energy. A bigger energy imbalance means more warming. In fact, Earth’s declining reflectivity is responsible for as much warming as all human emissions since the Industrial Revolution. Yet, climate models systematically underestimate the observed increase in EEI by between 10-40 percent. Furthermore, despite being a decision-critical measurement, there are only 26 years of global observational data on EEI, and it comes from one source at risk of observational gaps as soon as 2027. Without this data, we’d be blind to a major driving force of warming. And as conference presenters emphasized to a nodding room, “we can’t manage what we can’t measure.”

A second neglected piece of the warming puzzle is that warming induced emissions, which come from the CO2 released from carbon sinks like wetlands and permafrost as they deteriorate, are responsible for roughly a 0.2°C – 0.4°C warming increase and are not included in current climate projections. And, a third critical piece is that sulfur dioxide pollution and other human-made aerosols in our atmosphere could be masking an additional 0.2°C and 0.9°C of warming. Aerosols reflect sunlight, so cleaning up air pollution, while essential for human health, is part of why Earth is reflecting less sunlight. All of these undercounted sources add up. The result: we have even less time than we thought to decarbonize, and we are headed in a worse trajectory than current climate models and mainstream environmental discourse acknowledge. 

We are left with a climate problem that looks different, and worse, than we have recognized. The good news? Scientists are working on promising strategies to broaden and nuance our response, too. Attendees at the summit seemed to broadly agree that our current climate toolbox with instruments for mitigation and adaptation is absolutely essential, yet warrants expansion. With earth’s declining reflectivity and warming-induced emissions as significant contributors to rising temperatures, new tools in the climate toolbox can help us address their warming mechanisms directly. 

The set of strategies discussed under the headers “climate interventions,” “earth systems stabilization,” and “geoengineering” (choose your fighter) do just that. Among them are arctic rewilding, sea bed curtains, marine cloud brightening, stratospheric aerosol injection (SAI), cirrus cloud thinning, and space mirrors. Despite acting on different mechanisms, these tools are united under the same purpose as the mitigation and adaptation tools we continue to employ relentlessly: to save lives and alleviate suffering from the devastating impacts of climate change. We see these cruel impacts happening now, and we see them accelerating, and that is why scientists, activists, and policy analysts are even talking about adding out-of-the-box strategies. 

The path forward sounds daunting, but we draw hope from the dedication of the individuals committing their research, capital, influence, and brain power into moving this acknowledgement of our current climate situation from niche spaces like the Harpa to town halls and lawmaker offices across the globe. As for FAS, we’re doing our part to drive progress in the space we operate best – U.S. science policy. We are asking, in an era of climate overshoot – how can the U.S. government be prepared to make decisions about how new tools like SAI may fit into our climate toolkit? 

The ability to make these decisions doesn’t manifest overnight. It involves laying groundwork for education, funding, legal authorities, international collaborations, and a path to translate information into concrete decisions. This is why FAS is partnering with the Foundation for American Innovation (FAI) to construct a policy roadmap with step-by-step recommendations for U.S. executive branch, Congressional, and state leaders to advance the research base, technology, governance structures, and international collaboration mechanisms they need to assess whether and how SAI fits into a comprehensive U.S. climate policy. We’re charting a path to sound, evidence-based policy about SAI because we can’t accept the alternatives of decision paralysis or ill-considered, reactionary deployment. As with mitigation and adaptation, climate-impacted communities should not bear the brunt of our failure to prepare.  

We want our roadmap to feed into broader conversations about other interventions and global governance. Our ultimate goal: help advance scientific understanding about climate interventions and build climate policies that more effectively save and improve the lives of our communities here in the United States and around the world.

Interested in learning more or have thoughts about what to include in the roadmap? Please reach out to Julia Herrle (jherrle@fas.org) and Megan Husted (mhusted@fas.org).