Parties Tangle Over Discovery in Kiriakou Leak Case
The trial of former CIA officer John Kiriakou, who is accused of making unauthorized disclosures of classified information, has yet to begin. But prosecutors and defense attorneys are now locked in a dispute over what classified information must be provided to the defense and can be cleared for disclosure at trial.
The resolution of the current pre-trial arguments may have a decisive effect not only on the outcome of Mr. Kiriakou’s proceeding but on the future use of the Espionage Act to penalize leaks of classified information. That’s because the pending disagreements involving the nature of the charge will determine the standard by which the defendant will be judged.
“The government has no obligation to prove, and does not intend to prove, that the defendant [Kiriakou] intended to harm the United States,” prosecutors said in a September 26 motion that was unsealed last week.
“The government must prove only that the defendant had a ‘reason to believe’ that the information ‘could be used to the injury of the United States or to the advantage of any foreign nation’…. The defendant’s intent to injure or serve the United States is not at issue.”
Prosecutors rejected the contrary view of the defense that the government must demonstrate an intent by the defendant to harm the United States. In a separate pleading last week, they said that view reflects a “misplaced” reliance on a 2006 holding in the AIPAC case (US v. Rosen) in which the court imposed a more stringent “intent” requirement on the prosecution, particularly since the defendants there did not hold security clearances and were dealing with information transmitted orally rather than with classified documents.
“Rosen is distinguishable from this case… because Kiriakou transmitted the information electronically, not orally, and Kiriakou had a recognized obligation not to divulge classified, national defense information to those not entitled to receive it,” prosecutors said October 2. (The latest defense argument on the subject is still under seal.)
But whether an email message is more like “documentary” information or like transcribed “oral” information seems to be an open question for the Kiriakou court to decide, along with other fateful questions about the use of the Espionage Act in leak cases.
We are left with a climate problem that looks different, and worse, than we have recognized. The good news? Scientists are working on promising strategies to broaden and nuance our response, too.
A lot of the people who won in November promised voters a version of a government that works, whether answering the phone faster, clearing backlogs, cutting paperwork, or making help easier to access. Here’s how they can deliver.
Denice Ross, former U.S. Chief Data Scientist and Data Policy Institute lead at the Federation of American Scientists, will be honored for her stewardship of public data by the National Academy of Public Administration, where she has been named a Fellow.
Confirmation that the construction of the security perimeter and associated security infrastructure at RAF Lakenheath are still ongoing once again raises questions about whether U.S. nuclear weapons have already been deployed to the base.