At a House Judiciary Subcommittee hearing today, witnesses discussed the feasibility and advisability of legislating reforms to the state secrets privilege.
The state secrets privilege has been used by the executive branch to block discovery in civil litigation when the government believes that there is an unacceptable risk of disclosure of sensitive national security secrets. But on several occasions, the mere assertion of the privilege has led to termination of the lawsuit. It has effectively short-circuited the adjudication of claims against the government involving domestic surveillance, unlawful detention, and torture.
“I do believe thoughtful legislation is needed to insure that maximum and uniform efforts are made to strike the right balance between national security needs and fair judicial proceedings,” said the Hon. Patricia M. Wald, the retired chief judge of the DC Circuit Court of Appeals in testimony today.
Legislative intervention was also endorsed by H. Thomas Wells, Jr. (pdf), the president-elect of the American Bar Association, and by Kevin Bankston (pdf) of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, whose lawsuit on warrantless domestic surveillance has prompted state secrets claims by the government.
Patrick Philbin, a former deputy attorney general, argued (pdf) that any legislative proposal to permit judges to overrule the executive branch regarding the sensitivity of particular information “would be a mistake.”
The prepared statements from today’s hearing are posted here.
Last week, Senators Kennedy, Specter and Leahy introduced “The State Secrets Protection Act.” The text of that legislation is now available here.
Hurricanes cause around 24 deaths per storm – but the longer-term consequences kill thousands more. With extreme weather events becoming ever-more common, there is a national and moral imperative to rethink not just who responds to disasters, but for how long and to what end.
The program invites teams of researchers and local government collaborators to propose innovative projects addressing real-world transportation, safety, equity, and resilience challenges using mobility data.
The Pentagon’s new report provides additional context and useful perspectives on events in China that took place over the past year.
Successful NC3 modernization must do more than update hardware and software: it must integrate emerging technologies in ways that enhance resilience, ensure meaningful human control, and preserve strategic stability.