Policy on Controlled Unclassified Info Languishes
Three and a half years have passed since President Bush called for the establishment of a standardized government-wide format for the handling of “controlled unclassified information” (CUI) that would replace the dozens of different, incompatible controls on what had been known as “Sensitive But Unclassified” (SBU) information. More than a year has passed since President Bush declared that the new CUI framework was established.
But in practice, little has changed because the implementing policies and procedures have not yet been devised. An initial draft for comment is expected sometime this summer. Meanwhile, agencies continue to follow their previous, often problematic approaches.
“Department of Defense components are not to use any of the new CUI markings until the national level interagency policy has been issued, the DoD-level implementation guidance has been published, and the DoD CUI Transition Plan is completed,” wrote Under Secretary of Defense James R. Clapper, Jr. in an internal memorandum (pdf) last month. “Until such time, existing policy guidance pertaining to information such as For Official Use Only (FOUO), SBU, and DoD Unclassified Controlled Nuclear Information… must be strictly adhered to,” Gen. Clapper wrote.
The National Archives has requested $1.9 million for the Controlled Unclassified Information Office in FY 2010. “The office will establish standards and guidance for this type of information, and monitor department and agency compliance.”
Aside from increasing uniformity of controls on information, limits on the authorized use of such controls and other policy provisions remain to be defined.
The potential implication of these evidence gaps becomes more consequential when you look at how institutions actually make decisions day to day.
Every new institution inherits something – existing incentives, existing staff, decades of prior investment that shaped what’s possible.
This is not the first time Google has agreed to censor imagery at the behest of governments, but be warned: obfuscation at this broad level poses a direct threat to the public’s ability to monitor and scrutinize government operations.
America’s affordability problem is bigger than home prices and rents. The best housing policies make it easier to build homes, and recognize how housing connects to other domains.